Manuscript Review Form

On-line reviews of articles submitted to The Journal of Research for Educational Leaders will be conducted by reviewers selected from and by our editorial board. Submissions undergoing review will be accessible only to approved reviewers. Reviews will be electronically submitted to the journal editors. Reviewers' comments will be compiled and forwarded to the author electronically.

Reviewer's Name:

Reviewer's E-mail Address:

Article Number and Title:

1. Introduction

Article Introduction:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable

Comments

 

 

2. Methods

A. Sample:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

B. Instruments:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

C. Procedures:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

D. Design:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

E. Statistics/Analysis:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

 

 

3. Literature Review

A. Thorough and Appropriate:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

B. Research reviewed and critiqued in article:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

C. Organized and Focused:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

4. Results/Discussion

A. Conclusion Clear and Logical:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable

Comments

B. Practical Implications:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

C. Other:

Accept as is Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A

Comments

5. Writing Style, Grammar, APA format

 

Accept as is Accept with revision Unacceptable

Comments

6. Written Feedback to Authors

Comments


7. Recommendation for JREL

 

Accept as is
Accept with minor revision
Accept with major revision - Rewrite, resubmit and review
Reject - unsound
Reject - - inappropriate for JREL; the following journals are suggested:

 

 

Copyright © Journal of Research for Educational Leaders
N 473 Lindquist Center , The University of Iowa Iowa City, Iowa 52242-1529
Phone 319 335-5641 Fax 319 384-0587
Email: jrel@uiowa.edu
Map http://www.uiowa.edu/~maps/l/lc1.htm
Comments about the website to coe-webmaster@uiowa.edu